Best Toaster Ovens In Our Research

Best Toaster Oven Those who love to melt cheese on their bread would definitely find the toaster oven much more handy than an upright toaster. Indeed, a toaster oven serves a much greater function than simply toasting, but also baking and broiling. Selecting the best toaster oven is therefore critical since this useful kitchen device can even be used as a substitute to the microwave in certain instances. A selection of models were tested for this toaster oven review based on their performance in toasting small and medium sized foods such as toast, sandwiches, roasted chicken, cookies, brownies among other foods.

The Best Toaster Oven Recommendation

A good toaster oven review would necessarily involve analyzing customer comments, checking through articles contained in home cooking publications, looking up discussions on message boards and even talking to authors of toaster oven cookbooks. However, this review went even further to get a first hand impression of the performance of the different models by practically testing 40+ toaster ovens. This was achieved by practically toasting bread slices, roasted chicken, frozen pizzas and even baking cookie dough.  Click here to read how we choose the best oven.

#1 Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven – A Smart & Best Choice

Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven The high rating given by Good Housekeeping and Consumer Reports is not the only factor that gives the Breville BOV800XL a place in this review of the best toaster   oven . This smart oven excels in all the toasting and baking functions with even more special features that make it stand out from the crowd. Such features as the auto-eject rack, digital display, internal sensor and nine preset cooking functions make it easy to use and efficient in cooking. It may be expensive, but the extra features make it well worth the investment.

Read our full review of the Breville BOV800XL

#2 Cuisinart TOB-40 Toaster Oven – A Classic Toaster and Broiler

Cuisinart TOB-40 Toaster Oven The Cuisinart TOB-40 offers good quality in a simple design. This is a basic model (costs less than $100), but is far better than any lower-end variety. It is indeed a very good bargain considering how fast it can toast as well as broil or bake potatoes. You do not have to worry too much about cleaning sticky foods since it has a non-stick interior made of stainless steel. A couple of extra advantages with this toaster oven would be the fact that all accessories contained in it are dish-washer safe, plus it has a compact design that allows for efficient use of crowded kitchen surfaces.

Read our full review of the Cuisinart TOB-40

#3 Oster TSSTTVMNDG Digital Toaster Oven – Solution for Large Capacity

Oster TSSTTVMNDG Digital Toaster Oven For an affordable model that has the convection feature similar to other expensive versions, the Oster TSSTTVMNDG is your choice for best toaster oven. It therefore, comes as no surprise that this model receives recommendations by ‘Consumer Reports’. Some of the features contained in it include:

  • Simple temperature & time control
  • Several cooking features
  • Interior lighting
  • Dishwasher safe accessories

Perhaps the most evident benefit of this toaster oven is its large capacity that makes it especially suited to large families or anyone who does heavy cooking. The fact that it is a bit expensive should not deter those who are seeking a solution for large capacity cooking.

Read our full review of the Oster TSSTTVMNDG

How to Choose the Best Toaster Oven

When shopping for a toaster oven, you have to ask yourself some questions before making the final decision. We are listing some important factors here to help you do that. And that’s how we research toaster ovens and work out the top 3 selection above.



Having the best toaster oven ensures that your toast turns out just right every time. First, you want to think about the current counter top space that you have. A counter that is small or has very limited space because of other appliances may not be capable of having a large toaster oven come in. Make sure you measure everything. This will help you find one that fits. Most people recommend using under cabinet toaster ovens. Consider using a mountable toaster; it may be exactly what you are looking for.

Power Cord Length

It is good to consider measuring out where the toaster can be and how far it is going to be from your nearest outlet. the truth is that If it is not that close, you will find that it can ruin your investment and it will all be wasted. There is also danger involved. The ovens may have an extension cord, and it can pose as a hazard at some point.


Understand that the size of the toaster decides which one you should buy. If you think your family does not need a large toaster, then opt for a smaller one instead. If all you need is a toaster that can churn out a few toasters at once, then the smaller ones really are best, but those who want more at one time should really consider bigger toasters. If you plan on cooking chicken and other pizzas, you will find that it all depends on what you plan on using the oven for.


It is always good to think about the features you may want to have. You may possibly want a convection features or even a built in fan that can help blow out air throughout your food. This can actually help make sure the food is properly cooked and well balanced. It saves you electricity because of the short cooking time. Find a good toaster that can give you different types of setting to let you warm, reheat, or even defrost food. The best toaster oven can surely do all of that. It is always good to consider getting a toaster with the broil setting to cook meat as well. A light inside of the unit to let you see all of the food is also a really good thing to consider. If you need it for melting, this is the bet thing to consider using.


Above every other feature, safety is the biggest key to make sure you and your kids do not get hurt in any form. They should have a good rack that protects you so you can extend the food outwards. Some brands do not have specific models that allow for the food to be extended outwards easily. Avoid the ovens that are not well insulated since the exterior walls can be hot when they are being used. Don’t forget to consider looking into the warranty to see if you can get it fixed if something goes wrong. This can surely save you money in the future.